data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f0bae/f0bae5d17c9a0759bc8a8c7c4ed854588c9a42f6" alt="Broomstick bunny"
She dashes to her magic broom closet to grab her flying broomstick to keep up with him, but she had accidentally grabbed her magic sweeping broom, which starts sweeping with her on it before she lets go.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/eb355/eb3550905db460d639f7a801b848b39b20746962" alt="broomstick bunny broomstick bunny"
Bugs flees, stating, "Uh, pardon me, auntie, but uh, I've got a lot of trick-or-treatin' to catch up on so I'll bid you a civil adieu!", with the cackling witch chasing him throughout her house. While she's gone, Bugs suspects there's trouble afoot and makes to leave ("You know, my delicate inner sense of danger warns me that there's something faintly unhealthy in the atmosphere of this cottage"), but he's stopped at the door by Witch Hazel brandishing a meat cleaver. Sure enough, the last ingredient for the potion she was brewing earlier is a rabbit's clavicle. Seeing that her "rival" is actually a rabbit, Witch Hazel dashes off to consult her potion book. Bugs is about to drink the tea when he remembers that he's still wearing his mask, and takes it off. The jealous witch hatches a plot: she invites the disguised Bugs in for tea and prepares a brew containing various beauty enhancers. The genie in the mirror, also not realizing that Bugs is just a rabbit in a costume, admits that he actually finds Bugs far uglier. "I don't remember seeing her at any of the union meetings." After making a comment about Bugs's appearance, "Isn't she the ugliest little thing", she dashes to her magic mirror and asks it a second time who's the ugliest one of all. He calls on Witch Hazel, who, seeing his costume, mistakes him for an actual witch. Meanwhile, Bugs Bunny's out trick-or-treating dressed as a witch, his face hidden by an ugly green mask. Hazel explains to the audience that she's "deathly afraid" of getting prettier as she gets older.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/93668/93668184107b4a1b8118e5ede7221ed6ab5c687d" alt="broomstick bunny broomstick bunny"
The genie in the mirror replies that she, Witch Hazel, is the ugliest one of all, "By my troth, I will avow: there's none that's uglier than thou". As she goes about her business, she pauses at her magic mirror and asks it who's the ugliest one of all. It's Halloween night, and Witch Hazel's brewing some kind of magic potion.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f0bae/f0bae5d17c9a0759bc8a8c7c4ed854588c9a42f6" alt="Broomstick bunny"